Answering difficult questions when you’re trying to conceive

(A guest blog for NFAW from Dr Grace Lee Brindle)

If you’re struggling to conceive, you’ve probably heard a question or comment that stayed with you way after the conversation ended.

Most people mean well. They want to help, or they don’t know what to say, so they go for something that sounds comforting. (Or they aren’t thinking at all and say the first thing that comes into their head – not ideal!). Either way, sadly, these comments often minimise what you’re going through or suggest that it’s somehow in your control, and that you should be trying harder.

When you’re already carrying grief, worry and self-blame, even a throwaway line can hit hard. So, if a comment has hurt you, of course it has. You’re going through something unbelievably hard, and these comments can make you feel even more alone in the experience.

They are painful, and when you get them frequently, the desire to respond with something different to a polite nod and change of topic can grow.

Below are some of the questions and comments people hear most often, with a few ways you might respond, from a gentler option to a firmer one. You can use whatever fits you and the person in front of you, or nothing at all, depending on your energy (more on this later).

“Just relax, it’ll happen when you least expect it”

This can make it sound like infertility is your fault because you are too stressed. But infertility is a medical issue, and you can’t relax yourself into having a baby.

Gentler: “I know you mean well, but it’s a lot more complicated than that.”

Firmer: “Infertility is a medical condition. Relaxing won’t change that, and it isn’t something I can control.”

“Just stay positive!”

Staying hopeful can feel impossible some days, and this can leave you feeling it’s your fault if you can’t hold the hope. But you can’t positively think yourself into having a baby, and you’re allowed to feel how you feel.

Gentler: “Some days I feel hopeful and some days I don’t, and that’s okay.”

Firmer: “Positive thinking won’t change my fertility, and I need to be allowed to feel how I feel.”

“Have you tried…?”

Whether it’s a supplement, a holiday, or a diet their neighbour’s daughter’s hairdresser tried, unsolicited advice can leave you feeling you haven’t done enough. And the chances are, you’ve already researched it at 2am anyway.

Gentler: “Thanks, I’m following my clinic’s advice, so I’m in good hands.”

Firmer: “I know you’re trying to help, but I’d rather not get advice on this. There really is very little I haven’t tried, or at least thought of trying, by now.”

“My friend’s cousin had twins after ten years of IVF!”

These stories, often about someone they barely know, are usually shared to give you hope. But they can feel like pressure to keep going, or a reminder that someone else got their happy ending. Hearing that it took someone ten years can also feel terrifying, when you’re already wondering how much longer you can keep going. Every fertility journey is different. What these comments miss is awareness of the hardest thing you are holding – you have no idea if, let alone when, you might get your hoped-for outcome.

Gentler: “I’m really pleased for them. Every journey is so different though, so I try not to compare.”

Firmer: “I know you mean it kindly, but stories like that don’t really help me. Our situation is different, and we don’t know if it will happen for us.”

“So when are you having kids?”

It can seem like a casual question, but when you’ve been trying for months or years, it can feel absolutely crushing (and very intrusive).

Gentler: “We’ll share any news when we’re ready.”

Firmer: “That’s quite a personal question, and not one I want to answer.”

Keeping it vague: “Who knows what the future holds!” or “We’re not there at the moment.”

“Everything happens for a reason”

This can suggest your pain is deserved or part of a plan. Sometimes life is just really unfair, and not everything has a reason.

Gentler: “I’m not sure there is a reason, and when people say that, it can make me feel I might not be good enough to be a mum.”

Firmer: “I don’t find that helpful. Not everything happens for a reason.”

“At least you know you can get pregnant”

After a loss, this moves the focus away from the baby you’ve lost. The ultimate aim isn’t pregnancy, it’s a baby, and every loss deserves to be grieved, however early it happened.

Gentler: “I know you’re trying to find a positive, but right now I’m grieving and I don’t find that particularly reassuring.”

Firmer: “I’ve lost a baby, and I need space to grieve that.”

“You can always adopt”

Adoption is a big decision with its own process and challenges. It doesn’t take away the grief of not being able to conceive and is far from an “obvious solution”.

Gentler: “Adoption is a big decision, and it’s not one we’re ready to talk about. We’d still really like the chance to carry our own baby.”

Firmer: “Adoption isn’t a quick fix for infertility, and it’s our decision to make.”

“At least you’ve got one”

With secondary infertility, this can make you feel you’re not allowed to struggle. Two things can be true: you can be grateful for your child and still grieve the baby you’re hoping for.

Gentler: “I’m so grateful for them, and I still can’t turn off my need for another.”

Firmer: “Being grateful doesn’t stop this from really hurting.”

“Have mine for a weekend, that’ll put you off!”

This, or versions like it (e.g. “You wait, you don’t know what tired is until you have kids”), is usually meant as a joke, but it can hit hard when you’d give anything to be in their position.

Gentler: “I know it’s a joke, but it’s hard to hear right now. I would do anything to have what you have.”

Firmer: “Please don’t joke about that with me. It hurts.”

When you don’t have the energy

Some days you’ll feel able to explain what you’re going through, and that can feel really empowering. Other days you’ll have nothing left to give, and that’s okay too. You don’t owe anyone an answer, an explanation or education on infertility.

It can also help to think about who’s asking. With someone you’re close to, or will see often, it might feel worth the effort to explain what this is like for you, as a gentle conversation now could mean they support you better next time.

With an acquaintance or a distant relative, you might decide it isn’t worth your energy, and a short evasive answer is enough. Neither choice is wrong. You get to decide where your energy goes.

If you’re running on empty, these might help:

  • Keep a simple exit line ready, such as “I’d rather not talk about that today.”
  • Change the subject, or step away for a few minutes.
  • Ask a partner or trusted friend to step in or field questions for you, especially at events you’re dreading.
  • If you smiled along in the moment, it’s okay to come back to it later. You could message them, or talk in person, once you’ve had time to think about what you want to say.
  • Be kind to yourself afterwards. Try not to replay what you “should” have said. You got through a hard moment, and that’s enough.

Looking after yourself

Difficult comments are one of the many unseen parts of infertility, and they can have a real impact over time. If you’re finding it hard to cope, talking to someone who understands can really help. You can find support through Fertility Action’s Peer Support Groups (more information on the support group page).

You did not choose this, it is not your fault, and you are not alone.

Dr Grace Lee-Brindle, Clinical Psychologist

Subscribe to Our mailing list

Cum curabitu et consectetu, quod curabitu qui molesti, quam id metu: